UMG and Sony withdraw DistroKid subpoena motion in Suno case after distributor produces AI-detection documents

Credit: ssi77/Shutterstock

Universal Music Group and Sony Music Entertainment are ending their court fight to make DistroKid hand over data on its AI-detection tool for their copyright lawsuit against Suno, after the distributor produced the material.

The two majors told a federal court in Manhattan on Monday (November 16) that they are withdrawing their motion because DistroKid has now handed over documents covering the two requests still in dispute, weeks after refusing to produce them.

The notice, filed by UMG, its Capitol Records label, and Sony, can be read in full here.

The labels want to use the material as evidence in their original 2024 copyright lawsuit against AI music generator Suno, which is pending in federal court in Massachusetts.

“Since the Motion was filed, DistroKid has served supplemental responses and produced documents responsive to Narrowed Request Nos. 1 and 5,” the notice states. “In light of DistroKid’s supplemental responses and production, the Motion is moot.

“Counsel for Plaintiffs and DistroKid have conferred, and DistroKid consents to this notice of withdrawal.”

The withdrawal concerns only the subpoena. The labels’ copyright case against Suno continues.

They asked US District Judge Arun Subramanian to deny the motion as moot, without prejudice, which would leave them free to bring it again, and to close the New York proceeding.

The notice also asks the court to cancel DistroKid’s deadline to respond to the motion, which fell that same day.

And it asks the court to leave intact each party’s rights under the Suno case’s amended protective order, which governs how sensitive material handed over in the litigation can be used.

The notice does not say what the documents show or how many tracks DistroKid has flagged as AI-generated.

UMG and Sony asked the court in Manhattan on October 14 to enforce a subpoena they had served on DistroKid in September.

A subpoena is a legally binding demand for evidence, and DistroKid is not itself a defendant in the Suno case.

The subpoena originally contained 17 requests. Before going to court, the labels narrowed the dispute to two, both concerning DistroKid’s AI-detection tool, and said they would not pursue the rest “at this time.”

In that motion, the labels said DistroKid “refuses to produce a single document about the AI-detection tool” it had disclosed in its written responses. They also called the distributor “one of the primary conduits by which the streaming market is being flooded with AI-generated recordings.”

Their proposed court order sought monthly figures going back to when DistroKid began using a third-party “prediction model” to test tracks for AI generation.

The figures would cover how many recordings DistroKid sent to streaming services, how many it ran through the model, and how many the model scored as “likely AI-generated, whether in whole or in part.”

The labels also wanted “the total streams and royalties” earned by those flagged tracks, and the number attributed to Suno wherever the model identifies it as the actual or likely source.

A second request sought “the name and vendor of the prediction model,” along with the basis for statements about false positives that DistroKid made in an October 9 supplemental response to the subpoena.

Suno’s central defense in the Massachusetts case is that training its AI on copyrighted recordings without a license is fair use. One question a court asks when weighing that defense is whether the use harms the market for the original works.

In their motion, UMG and Sony described the DistroKid data as “highly relevant information that only DistroKid possesses,” and said their requests were “proportional to a case in which the market effect of AI-generated music is a central contested question.”

The motion cited an estimate, taken from UMG’s own lawsuit against the distributor in Delaware, that DistroKid delivered nearly 12 million tracks to a single unnamed streaming service between March and September this year. The labels said that was more than half of all tracks the service received, and more than every other distributor combined.

In the labels’ account, DistroKid had argued that data on the AI music it distributes “has no bearing” on how Suno built and trained its models.

If the figures show Suno-made tracks reaching streaming services in volume and earning royalties, the labels could use them to argue that Suno’s output competes with the recordings it was trained on.

The first Suno case covers 560 of the labels’ recordings. With damages set by law at up to USD $150,000 for each work found to be willfully infringed, those recordings carry theoretical exposure of up to $84 million, excluding the labels’ separate claim that Suno stream-ripped recordings from YouTube.

A second lawsuit, filed by the labels on September 18, covers a further 60,202 recordings, carrying a theoretical maximum of just over $9 billion on the same basis.

Warner Music Group, originally a co-plaintiff in the first case, settled with Suno in November 2025.

The labels and DistroKid first told the court they “are working on a resolution” in a joint filing signed on October 27, as MBW reported.

In a statement to Billboard on October 16, DistroKid said it is a third party in the litigation and is “committed to transparency and will continue to cooperate with the legal process.”

In their October motion, the labels told the court that the Suno case’s protective order means nothing DistroKid hands over in that case can be used in UMG’s separate lawsuit against it in Delaware.

Monday’s notice winds down one of several disputes over evidence held by companies outside the Suno case.

NVentures, the venture capital arm of NVIDIA, asked a federal court in California on November 10 to block the labels’ demand that it testify, describing itself as a “passive minority investor.”

In the first Suno case, the deadline for either side to ask the judge to decide the case without a trial is June 22, 2027.

UMG and Sony are also fighting a bid by Suno to pause their second lawsuit entirely.

In a filing last Friday (November 13), they warned that under Suno’s plan, its newer models and business conduct would be “examined nowhere until at least 2028.”


The subpoena dispute ran alongside a separate lawsuit that UMG filed against DistroKid in Delaware federal court on September 15, alleging copyright infringement and deceptive trade practices.

That complaint alleges that “DistroKid is flooding platforms with AI-generated ‘slop’ that siphons revenue and listeners from the legitimate artists and rightsholders.”

Sony is not a party to the Delaware case, in which DistroKid has until December 4 to respond.Music Business Worldwide

Related Posts