Producer sues Travis Scott, Don Toliver, and Sony Music, claiming he owns half the master of JackBoys track ‘What To Do?’

Credit: (Left) Christian Bertrand/Shutterstock and (R) Hardstone Psycho promo
Travis Scott and Don Toliver

Israeli producer Niv Kalisky, who works as Early Yellow, is suing Travis Scott, Don Toliver, and Sony Music over the 2019 JackBoys track What To Do?

Kalisky claims the track was built on a recording of his called Moazin99bpm, and that he has not been paid any master royalties for its use in the nearly seven years since What To Do? was released.

He is asking the court to declare that he owns 50% of the What To Do? master recording, and to award him at least half of what that recording has earned.

The complaint was filed in New York federal court on Tuesday (November 17). The filing, obtained by MBW, can be read in full here.

The lawsuit also names Sheck Wes and producers Mike Dean, London Cyr, and Jenius as defendants.

Five corporate defendants are named too: Sony Music Entertainment, Epic Records, Cactus Jack Records, LaFlame Enterprises, and London Cyr Productions.

What To Do? appeared on JackBoys, a 2019 album that the complaint says debuted at No.1 on the Billboard 200.

The track was released by Cactus Jack Records under exclusive license to Sony‘s Epic Records, the filing says.

Kalisky is already credited on What To Do?, the complaint notes.

“As is customary, Plaintiff is publicly credited as ‘Produced by Earlyyellow00’ on the Apple Music and Spotify credit listings, among other public outlets, including being listed by the Defendants as a ‘composer,’ ‘lyricist,’ ‘songwriter,’ and a ‘studio producer’ for the Infringing Work,” the filing reads.

The lawsuit centers on Kalisky‘s rights in the master recording of the track and the royalties that recording generates.

According to the complaint, What To Do? has been streamed more than 270 million times on Spotify and played more than 60 million times on YouTube.

The filing says Kalisky emailed Moazin99bpm to a representative for Cyr and Jenius in May 2019, and again in July 2019.

On October 30, 2019, Cyr emailed Kalisky a beat that incorporated Moazin99bpm, sending it “for review and approval,” the complaint states.

That beat was later used in What To Do?, which was released less than two months later, Kalisky alleges.

The complaint claims that the instrumental parts of the two recordings, including the chords and how they are voiced, are identical, “with the only difference between the two works being the addition of a vocal performance” by Scott, Toliver, and Sheck Wes.

Citing an exhibit attached to the filing, it claims the track contains at least 16 “similarities and identical copies of musical material” from Kalisky‘s recording.

Kalisky first wrote to Sony and Epic demanding payment in August 2020, according to the complaint.

In June 2025, an Israeli lawyer acting for Kalisky contacted Scott‘s lawyers and offered the defendants a license, the filing says.

Kalisky says he “received no suitable offer, answer, or response from the Defendants.”

His current lawyer, Justin M. Jacobson, sent further notices in June and July this year.

On July 6, a lawyer for Scott replied: “Confirming receipt of your email below. We are looking into this matter and will get back to you as soon as possible,” according to the complaint.

On October 16, Jacobson filed copyright takedown notices against What To Do? with Spotify, Pandora, Apple Music, SoundCloud, Deezer, Tidal, and YouTube, the complaint states.

Sony and Epic then challenged the takedowns, filing counter-notices with Apple Music on October 28, Spotify on November 5, and YouTube on November 9, the complaint alleges.

According to Kalisky, those counter-notices told the platforms that his takedowns were a “mistake” or a “misidentification,” and stated: “Provider Asserts Rights.”

Under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, anyone filing a counter-notice must state, under penalty of perjury, a good-faith belief that the material was removed “as a result of mistake or misidentification.”

The filing says What To Do?, which had been taken down, was then reinstated on Apple Music, Spotify, YouTube, and iTunes.

Kalisky‘s complaint alleges that “the business model of utilizing the valuable intellectual property owned by the Plaintiff without paying or negotiating proper licensing has been an extremely lucrative practice for the Defendants who continue with its willful unauthorized usage and monetization of the Plaintiff’s protected work despite receiving several notices of breaches and even after valid ‘takedown’ notices were filed by the Plaintiff.”

It adds that Sony and Epic filed their counter-notices “to fraudulently dispute the validly issued ‘takedown’ notices submitted by the Plaintiff to permit the Defendants to continue its illegal monetization scheme further violating the creator’s rights in the protected work.”

The complaint does not put a single figure on the total damages Kalisky is seeking.

He is asking for his actual losses plus the defendants’ profits from the track, with the complaint listing 44 categories of income it says should be counted.

Those include touring revenue, endorsements, merchandising, and the defendants’ “equity interests in Spotify,” to the extent their value relates to the track.

As an alternative, the complaint seeks damages set by law of USD $150,000 “for each act of infringement.”

US copyright law caps those damages at USD $150,000 per work infringed, even where the infringement is found to be willful, and the lawsuit concerns a single recording.

It also seeks at least USD $250,000 for unfair competition, USD $250,000 over the counter-notices it claims were false, and USD $500,000 for profiting unfairly at his expense.

Those three minimums total USD $1 million.

Separately, the complaint argues that Kalisky is a co-owner of the What To Do? recording alongside the six individual defendants, and is owed no less than 50% of its total earnings.

Kalisky is asking the court for a permanent ban on the “reproduction, distribution, sale, public performance, or other use or exploitation” of the track.

If granted, that order could take What To Do? off Spotify, Apple Music, and other services.

The complaint says Moazin99bpm was registered with the US Copyright Office on June 25, 2026, six and a half years after What To Do? was released.

Under US law, damages set by law and legal fees are generally unavailable for infringement that began after a work was published but before it was registered, unless registration came within three months of publication.

Kalisky‘s complaint dates the first publication of Moazin99bpm to December 27, 2019, the day What To Do? came out.

In March, a federal judge in Manhattan ruled in a separate case against Scott that the plaintiff could not claim damages set by law, or legal fees, for any infringement that began before her copyright registration took effect.

That lawsuit was brought by singer-songwriter Victory Boyd over the 2023 track Telekinesis, which also features SZA and Future.

Boyd dismissed the case in June, on terms that bar her from bringing the same claims again.

“This is not Defendants first public instance of unauthorized usage as Defendants have a history of such actions,” Kalisky‘s complaint states, citing an exhibit.

In October, songwriters Dion Norman and Derrick Ordogne dropped their lawsuit against Scott and Sony Music, which claimed his tracks Stargazing and Til Further Notice used an uncleared sample.

Kalisky‘s lawsuit comes a month after another producer filed a royalty claim against Sony Music in New York federal court.

Ishmael Sadiq Montague, a co-producer of Chris Brown‘s Party, sued Sony for roughly USD $1.25 million, alleging in part that it had paid him half his agreed producer royalty rate.

In a statement provided to AllHipHop, Kalisky‘s lawyers Justin M. Jacobson and Daniel Cruz Hernandez said: “Today we filed suit on behalf of our client, producer Early Yellow, against Travis Scott, Don Toliver, Sheck Wes, and Sony/Epic, among others, for the unauthorized use of Early Yellow’s work on the platinum hit ‘What To Do’ as part of the ‘Jackboys’ project.”

Jacobson and Cruz Hernandez added: “Producers are becoming more aware of their rights and the need to properly protect themselves. As a result, today our client chose to stand up for what he deserves and believes in and we are here to support him in this endeavor.”Music Business Worldwide

Related Posts