Peanuts music catalog owner settles copyright lawsuit against GameMill over Snoopy video game soundtrack

Photo credit: GameMill Entertainment
Snoopy & The Great Mystery Club

Lee Mendelson Film Productions (LMFP) has reached a settlement in principle in its copyright lawsuit against GameMill Entertainment, the publisher of the video game Snoopy & The Great Mystery Club.

US District Judge Denise Cote dismissed the case in New York federal court on November 9, after the two sides told the court they had agreed to settle.

Under the order, which can be read in full here, the dismissal becomes permanent unless either side asks to reopen the case by December 7.

The suit, filed on May 20 against Madcow LLC, which does business as GameMill, alleged that the game’s soundtrack copied two Vince Guaraldi compositions from the Peanuts TV specials: Linus and Lucy and Skating.

LMFP, which publishes Guaraldi‘s Peanuts catalog, sought damages that it estimated would exceed USD $300,000.

It also asked the court to order GameMill to stop exploiting the two compositions.

Neither LMFP nor GameMill has made the terms of the settlement public.

According to the complaint, GameMill licensed the Peanuts characters for the game from Peanuts Worldwide, but did not license the Guaraldi compositions from LMFP.

The game was released on PS5, Xbox Series X|S, Nintendo Switch, and PC on October 10, 2025, and a Nintendo Switch 2 version followed in March 2026. At the time of filing, it retailed for USD $39.99 for the Standard Edition and USD $49.99 for the Deluxe Edition, the complaint states.

The complaint claims that the defendants “never sought Plaintiff’s permission – even though there can be little doubt that music of this nature and stature requires a license for use – but instead created music substantially similar to (and thus infringing upon) the Guaraldi Compositions without authorization, as the soundtrack for a Peanuts video game.”

It alleges that GameMill engaged “one or more other persons to compose and record music for the GameMill Game that was very similar – but not identical – to the Guaraldi Compositions.”

The filing also claims that GameMill “expected that most players of the GameMill Game would not even realize that they were hearing anything other than the Guaraldi Compositions, and perhaps even believe themselves to be hearing the actual Peanuts recordings as performed by Vince Guaraldi.”

“GameMill self-evidently wanted the Peanuts imagery in the GameMill Game to be paired with the Peanuts music, but, equally self-evidently, did not want to pay Plaintiff for rights to use it,” the complaint states.

The lawsuit quotes Andy Koehler, GameMill‘s Head of Publishing, who it says wrote on December 19, 2025, that “the creator of the music focused on honoring the recognizable atmosphere and instrumentation style associated with the [Peanuts] brand.”

LMFP cited that statement as an admission that GameMill had access to Guaraldi‘s compositions.

LMFP hired musicologist Dr. Ethan Lustig to analyze a 4.5-hour video playthrough of the game.

According to the complaint, Lustig identified 192 instances of 17 distinct music cues, accounting for 92.6% of the playthrough.

He found strong musical similarities to Linus and Lucy, Skating, or both in 15 of those cues, which ran for 89.6% of the playthrough.

The complaint singles out two versions of a Success cue, which together play 34 times in the playthrough.

That cue plays only when a player completes a task or challenge, according to LMFP.

The complaint contends that GameMill designed the game this way “specifically to set up a reward structure for the player, whereby the player is rewarded with the most iconic piece from the Guaraldi Compositions only upon successful completion of a task or challenge.”

The suit also targeted up to 10 unnamed defendants, including whoever composed, recorded, arranged, and produced the music.

As an alternative to actual damages and profits, LMFP said it could elect statutory damages of up to USD $150,000 per work infringed, the ceiling for willful infringement.

With two compositions at issue, that capped statutory damages at USD $300,000, though LMFP also sought legal fees.

Unless the case is reopened, Judge Cote will not rule on whether the game’s music, which was allegedly written to evoke Guaraldi‘s work, infringed LMFP‘s copyrights.

The GameMill case was one of four copyright lawsuits that LMFP filed on May 20.

The others targeted auction house Heritage Auctions, accessories maker Buckle-Down Inc., and the US Department of the Interior.

The Heritage Auctions and Buckle-Down suits alleged unlicensed use of Linus and Lucy in social media posts.

The government suit concerned the alleged use of Guaraldi‘s arrangement of O Tannenbaum in a digital holiday card.

In August, LMFP announced that it had resolved the Buckle-Down and government cases.

According to court filings, Buckle-Down agreed to pay USD $27,500, and the federal government agreed to pay USD $20,000.

In the Heritage Auctions case, the two sides were reportedly granted a 60-day adjournment of case deadlines in September to pursue settlement talks.

Separately, LMFP reached a licensing agreement with CBS in June after Linus and Lucy was performed on the final episode of The Late Show with Stephen Colbert.

Proceeds from the CBS deal will be donated to World Central Kitchen.

“A principal goal of our enforcement actions is to educate individuals, businesses, and government entities about the need to obtain written license agreements to use music in a commercial setting,” LMFP Chairman Jason Mendelson said at the time.

When the suits were filed in May, LMFP‘s lead attorney, Marc Jacobson, said: “Unauthorized use doesn’t just violate the law, it erodes the exclusivity and artistic integrity that make these compositions meaningful to generations of fans.

“These legal actions convey that LMFP will no longer tolerate companies using their property without a license, especially in this era of instant digital sharing, and that the rights of creators and the protection of iconic cultural assets must be vigorously enforced.”

Peanuts Worldwide, which owns the rights to Charlie Brown, Snoopy, and the other characters, was not a party to the GameMill suit.

In March, Sony Music Entertainment (Japan) and Sony Pictures Entertainment took majority control of Peanuts Worldwide‘s parent company, Peanuts Holdings, completing a deal announced in December 2025 that raised Sony Group‘s stake from 39% to 80%.

LMFP was founded in 1963 by Lee Mendelson, the executive producer of the Peanuts TV specials, who died in 2019.Music Business Worldwide

Related Posts