Now is the time to embrace change and The Age of Ideas

MBW Views is a series of op-eds from eminent music industry people… with something to say.

The following MBW op/ed comes from Darren Hemmings, Founder of Motive Unknown, a prominent London-based digital marketing business working in music and music tech, which celebrates its 15th anniversary this month.

This week, the company launched a new retail division, led by Charlie Biles, with clients including Rough Trade, Sub Pop and Bertus/Musiconvinyl.

Here, Hemmings argues that social media’s grip on music marketing is fading fast, and that artists and labels who own their data and build direct relationships with fans are best placed for what comes next, an era he calls: “The Age of Ideas”.


As Motive Unknown turns 15, it understandably gives one reason to pause and reflect on how much has changed in the time since I started this company as a one-man outfit back in 2011.

It is ironic, then, to reflect on the current state of affairs and feel a genuine sense of deja vu, as things almost come full circle back to where we were back when downloads were still a thing, Facebook.com ruled the social roost and Spotify had something like 12 employees.

Granted, all of those things have changed immeasurably since then. Facebook is now Meta, Spotify is massive, and the internet has proven itself both a massive force for good, and a monstrous tool for evil.

Really though, the constant force that established itself all those years ago was social media, and for the best part of Motive Unknown’s lifetime, that has been the dominant platform upon which all marketing has been executed.

Ever the contrarians of course, I can say with some pride that we never saw the world that way. To myself, and the ever-growing team I have built around me (now around 30-strong!), the view was, and is, that the main problem to solve in music marketing is connecting artists with fans in a meaningful, authentic way (two words so painfully overused as to now carry substantially less meaning!) and – crucially – creating worlds in which data was leveraged wherever possible to deliver more back to the artist and/or their label.

In that sense, one might argue that far too much focus was placed on social media. Followers carried (in fact, arguably still carry) more value than reality reflected. Engagement was great but increasingly superficial, and on the whole, it felt like what everyone was really doing was building value for others: Meta, Google, TwXtter and so on.

As social has grown, however, it has started to flame itself out. Before AI flooded the plain with slop, the algorithms were already hard at work decoupling artists from their audiences in favour of cat videos, or the latest amusement from accounts like Archbishop of Banterbury.

What we now have then, is a world where social is worth less and less – and everyone is starting to panic.

When I say everyone, I mean businesses I directly chat to. Multiple labels have approached us in recent months, all with much the same issue: engagement is plunging and said business simply does not know what to do now. It is as if that central pinion holding all marketing together just got ripped out.

Ironically, this is where I have licence to feel quietly vindicated. Why? Because for 15 years, myself and my senior team colleagues have long held a view that artists and labels needed to own their own data, and leverage that to ensure they were empowered as much as was humanly possible in order to connect with audiences and create amazing experiences that ensure two things happen: first, the fans have reason to love this band for a lifetime, and second, that the artist gets to make money from that, ensuring they can continue to grow and succeed. Achieving both meant doing more than just building superficial metrics.

At Motive Unknown, we always believed that there were no ‘silver bullet’ solutions. As a colleague wisely phrased it: “frameworks, not hacks”. I have seen more startups come and go – all making outsized promises – than I care to remember. All made the same error: they believe tech was the answer to everything, and that, per the techno utopian philosophies that abound today courtesy of Musk and Thiel et al, everything in culture could be fixed if you just built the right product.

In reality, marketing is a nuanced exercise. One might argue that the core principles underpinning it have not changed in a century. Sure, the platforms keep changing – radio to TV to internet to whatever this mess is we live in now – but the underlying principles? They never changed.

I have often said that all marketing books are just a re-write of “How To Win Friends And Influence People”, a book first published in 1936, and I stand by that.

“As we move into this new era, which I call The Age of Ideas, I feel we are moving into a place where perhaps marketing around artists can align far, far more with the vision of the artists themselves, and in turn bring so much more impact to how all marketing is undertaken.”

So, as social diminishes in value, I feel proud that here at Motive Unknown, we continue along the path we were always on: placing the artist first, and working to build value. It is a philosophy that worked so well, we ported it over to the world of Music Tech, which now accounts for 50% of our business, such has been its growth streak.

It has also allowed us to take all that wisdom and create a third branch – the newly-announced Retail Division – to the company, focused on driving ecommerce direct-to-consumer sales for businesses like Rough Trade or Sub Pop, alongside less music-focused legendary arts institutions that I frustratingly can’t name just yet.

So how has this all come full circle?

Prior to social’s absolute dominance, the internet was a more freewheeling, experimental, positive place. Whilst we are not back to that entirely – yet – the fact remains that everyone is getting tired of marching to Big Tech’s drum, and instead whole generations are now seeking out more singular, creative experiences. This has echoes of the marketing I undertook back when I started the company; creating unique, amazing websites, and interactive experiences that provided a deeper point of connection with the music and the artists involved.

AI – yes, it’s time to mention it – is proving to be a complicated, divisive technology. Much like the internet itself, it is proving to deliver all manner of both brilliant and terrible things.

One of the positive things I would argue it has delivered, however, is the means for artists and their teams to explore further creative possibilities that allow a level of expression that matches the vision of the artists themselves.

Ask any artist how they’d feel if social media vanished tomorrow and 99 times out of 100 the answer will likely be “massively relieved”.

As we move into this new era, which I call The Age of Ideas, I feel we are moving into a place where perhaps marketing around artists can align far, far more with the vision of the artists themselves, and in turn bring so much more impact to how all marketing is undertaken.

I am here for it. My team is here for it. We can’t wait to see how this next age evolves how everyone connects with music itself.

Music Business Worldwide

Related Posts